Disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never affects our recommendations. Learn more.
Buying real estate leads can fill your calendar, or burn a few thousand dollars a month with nothing to show for it. The difference is rarely the vendor. It is whether you know your break-even number before you sign and answer every lead within minutes after you do.
This guide covers the six main ways to buy leads, published prices, a break-even calculator, contract traps, a 10-question vendor checklist and the follow-up system that decides whether paid leads pay off.
Last checked: November 2026. Prices checked: November 2026. Compliance notes are US-specific.
At a glance: six ways to buy real estate leads
| Model | Examples | How you pay | Lead type | Typical intent |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Portal advertising | Zillow Premier Agent, Realtor.com Connections Plus | Monthly spend set by market | Mostly buyers | Active: they asked about a specific home |
| Pay at close (referral fee) | Zillow Preferred, Realtor.com ReadyConnect Concierge | Share of your commission when a deal closes | Buyers and sellers | Pre-screened by the platform |
| Pay-per-lead packages | Market Leader, Real Geeks lead packages | Monthly package for a set or estimated number of leads | Buyers and sellers | Mixed, many early browsers |
| Platforms with ads included | Ylopo, CINC, Real Geeks | Platform fee plus lead or ad packages | Buyers and sellers | Mostly early, long nurture |
| Seller-lead offers | Zillow seller connections, home-value ad packages | Referral fee or monthly package | Sellers | From curious to ready to list |
| Expired and FSBO data | REDX, Vulcan7 | Monthly data subscription | Sellers (prospecting lists) | Motivated, but you call them cold |
The first five deliver people who raised their hand. The last one sells contact data, so you are prospecting, and different rules apply.
1. Portal advertising: Zillow Premier Agent and Realtor.com
According to Zillow’s Premier Agent page, buyers who click “Contact agent” or request a tour on Zillow, Trulia, StreetEasy or HotPads are passed to Premier Agent partners. After a call or confirmed tour, Zillow assigns that buyer to you “for all listings across Zillow.”
Pricing: Zillow says the price “varies by market, home values, expected connections, and more,” and that “The average cost per connection in major metro areas is $223 and $139 in non-major metros.” It says “Contracts are not required,” but recommends 6 months as the minimum “to see the most value.”
Lead types: live calls, emails, tours and pre-approved buyers. Zillow states that “agents using Premier Agent close 60% more transactions than those who don’t.” That is Zillow’s own data, not an independent study.
Realtor.com’s Connections Plus page says it delivers buyer leads from people who “take action on listings in your market” and sends automatic first messages. It publishes no prices; you contact Realtor.com sales for a quote.
Who it suits: buyer’s agents who can answer the phone all day. See our guides on whether Zillow Premier Agent is worth it and Realtor.com leads.
2. Pay at close: referral-fee programs
You pay nothing upfront. The platform screens the consumer, connects them to you, and takes a share of your commission if the deal closes.
Zillow Preferred. Zillow’s Preferred FAQ calls it “the next evolution of the Flex program,” says participation “is by invitation only,” and says “The only required expense is a Follow Up Boss (FUB) subscription.” Its pricing page says the fee is a percentage “of the full commission you expect to earn,” that buyer fees vary by market, transaction price and connection delivery date, and that “The success fee for all seller originated connection transactions is 40%.”
Realtor.com ReadyConnect Concierge. Realtor.com says “Opcity is now ReadyConnect Concierge”. Its Concierge page says you “only pay a referral fee on closed transactions.” Reps screen consumers on intent, timeframe and pre-approval, alert matching agents, and live-transfer the first agent to claim. The fee percentage is not published.
Who it suits: agents with little marketing cash but strong phone skills. Skip it if you cannot take a live transfer on the spot.
3. Pay-per-lead packages
These vendors run the ads and hand you the leads. Market Leader says it offers “a committed number of exclusive leads from your area” each month but lists no prices. Real Geeks publishes its numbers:
- Platform: $399/month plus a $500 one-time setup fee, 2 users.
- Social Lead Package (Facebook and Instagram): $299/month, about 20 to 40 buyer leads a month.
- Search Lead Package (Google and Bing): $599/month, about 20 to 40 buyer leads a month.
- Seller Lead Package (Google property valuation ads): $599/month, about 10 to 15 seller leads a month.
- Terms of 6 or 12 months, with a credit if the guaranteed minimum is not delivered.
Lead counts depend on market tier, and the page does not say whether ad spend is included. Ask.
4. Lead-gen platforms with ads included
These bundle an IDX website, CRM, ad management and automated texting.
- Ylopo lists no prices. Plans include a home-search website, buyer and seller lead generation and AI text nurture, with AI voice “included from Growing Team up.” Its calculator treats monthly ad spend as a separate input.
- CINC shows “Request Pricing” on all plans and lists add-ons: CINC AI “starting at $200/mo” and a dialer at “3 lines for $75/mo.”
Who it suits: teams with an ISA, or an agent who works the database daily. If you log in twice a week, the leads will go cold.
5. Seller-lead vendors
Seller leads tend to cost more per lead. Real Geeks charges the same $599 for about 10 to 15 seller leads as for 20 to 40 search buyer leads, and Zillow takes 40% on seller connections. Many home-value leads are curious owners, so ask each vendor how it defines a “seller lead” and plan monthly market updates for the ones not ready yet.
6. Expired and FSBO data lists
REDX lists single lead types (GeoLeads, Expired, FSBO, FRBO, Pre-Foreclosure) at $60/month each. Bundles are CORE at $199/month, CONNECT at $299/month with a single-line dialer and PRO at $349/month with a three-line dialer.
Vulcan7 offers three plans with expired leads in all of them and FSBO, FRBO and neighborhood search in higher tiers. It publishes no prices and says “No long-term contract required.”
You call these owners first, so US telemarketing rules apply. The FTC says registry users must sync their lists “at least every 31 days,” and violators “may be subject to fines of up to $53,088 per violation.” Our expired listing playbook has the scripts. Check with your broker or state association for how this applies to you.
How to calculate your break-even before you buy
Every source comes down to one number: what it costs to close one deal, against what you keep from it. Copy these formulas into a spreadsheet.
Net commission per closing = sale price x commission rate x your split Monthly cost = platform fee + lead or ad spend + extra tools Cost per closing = monthly cost / closings from this source Break-even closings per month = monthly cost / net commission per closing Break-even conversion rate = monthly cost / (leads per month x net commission per closing) Pay-at-close cost = gross commission x referral fee % (check: before or after your split?)
Worked example (illustrative numbers, not market data)
| Input | Upfront pay-per-lead source | Pay-at-close source |
|---|---|---|
| Sale price and commission | $400,000 x 2.5% = $10,000 gross | $400,000 x 2.5% = $10,000 gross |
| Your split | 80% | 80% |
| Cost | 100 leads x $40 + $300 platform = $4,300/month | 35% fee on gross = $3,500 per closing |
| Net to you per closing | $8,000 | ($10,000 – $3,500) x 80% = $5,200 |
| Break-even | 0.54 closings a month (0.54% conversion) | No upfront risk |
| If 1.5% of leads close | 1.5 closings: $2,867 per closing, $7,700 profit | Each closing still costs $3,500 |
Upfront leads get cheaper per closing as your conversion improves; a referral fee costs the same on every deal. Conversion is the variable you control. Add your hours at an hourly value, and judge a source over 6 to 12 months, not 30 days.
Contract and referral-fee traps: read the terms
- Fee windows. Zillow’s Preferred compliance policies say a fee is owed on the first two transactions you complete with a Zillow Preferred lead “during the two years after you received the lead.” Ask every pay-at-close vendor how long its tail runs.
- Existing clients. Zillow exempts a prior relationship only with documented two-way communication “within the 60 days prior” to lead delivery, and notice “within 14 days of lead delivery.” Check your CRM before you claim a lead.
- Deadlines. Zillow wants closing documents “within 4 calendar days” of closing.
- Fee changes. Zillow can change Preferred fees on 15 days’ notice. Ask whether any vendor can change terms mid-contract.
- Minimum terms and renewal. Ask how to cancel and whether the contract renews automatically.
- Gross vs net. Know whether the fee comes off before your broker split.
- Who signs. A referral agreement may bind your brokerage, so show it to your broker first.
NAR explains that Section 8 of RESPA generally bans payments for referring settlement business, but Section 8(c) “allows for cooperative fees to be paid between real estate licensees, including referral fees.” Check with your broker or state association for how this applies to you. Outside the US, check your local regulator or real estate association.
How to vet a lead vendor: 10 questions
Send these before any demo. Example written by Realty Nodes:
- Are the leads exclusive, or shared? With how many agents?
- How is a “lead” defined: form fill, call, tour request, home-value lookup?
- Where do leads come from: your site, Google, Facebook, a resold list?
- Is ad spend included, or billed on top?
- What is the minimum term, how do I cancel, and does it auto-renew?
- Do you credit invalid leads (wrong number, fake name, other agents)?
- For pay-at-close: what percentage, from gross or net, for how many deals and how long?
- How was consent to contact collected, and does it cover my calls and texts?
- Do leads go straight into my CRM with the source tagged?
- Can I call three current agents in a market like mine?
On question 8: the FCC rule at 47 CFR 64.1200 requires “prior express written consent” for autodialed or prerecorded telemarketing calls to cell phones, meaning a signed written agreement “that clearly authorizes the seller” to call that number. Ask to see the vendor’s consent language.
Speed to lead and follow-up: the real conversion lever
Many inquiries never get a fast answer. In Pied Piper’s 2026 study of 2,198 phone and website inquiries to offices of 21 large brands, reported by Florida Realtors, 68% of website inquiries got no response within 24 hours and 10% heard from an agent within an hour. In a 2024 secret-shopper test, Mike DelPrete found an average response time of 8 hours and 17 minutes (median 39 minutes), and nearly half of inquiries went unanswered.
So a reply in five minutes plus steady follow-up puts you ahead. Set it up once:
- Route every vendor’s leads into one CRM, tagged by source.
- Send an instant personal-sounding text, then call within five minutes.
- Call again the same day and the next morning.
- Move non-responders to a weekly touch for a month, then monthly listings or market updates.
Our speed-to-lead guide covers routing and auto-texts, and our follow-up sequence gives a 7-touch plan for the first 14 days.
Copy-ready scripts
Instant text. Example written by Realty Nodes:
Hi [First name], this is [Your name] with [Brokerage]. Thanks for asking about [address]. I can answer questions now or set up a showing. Is a quick call in the next few minutes OK?
First call. Example written by Realty Nodes:
Hi [First name], it's [Your name], the local agent. You asked about [address] a few minutes ago. What caught your eye about it? [Listen.] Are you hoping to move in the next few months, or still getting a feel for the area? I can send you three similar homes today and we can see one or two this week.
Track the right numbers
Fill this in monthly. Cost per appointment shows early whether a source works; cost per closing shows whether it pays.
| Source | Spend | Leads | Cost per lead | Appointments | Cost per appointment | Closings | Cost per closing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [Source A] | $ | $ | $ | $ | |||
| [Source B] | $ | $ | $ | $ |
Common mistakes
- Starting several sources at once, so you cannot tell which works.
- Comparing cost per lead instead of cost per closing.
- Leaving leads in the vendor’s app instead of your CRM.
- Cold texting purchased data lists with no documented consent.
When buying real estate leads is a bad idea
- You cannot answer within minutes and have no ISA or partner.
- You have no follow-up system, so long-term leads disappear.
- Your cash runway is short. If you cannot fund 6 months before the first closing, start with pay-at-close or your sphere.
- Your average price is low, which pushes the break-even conversion rate out of reach.
- Your sphere is untouched. Past clients cost less; see our referrals guide.
Build owned channels alongside paid leads
Paid leads stop when you stop paying. Put part of your budget into channels you own: your website and IDX search, a Google Business Profile, a seller landing page, an email list and your sphere. Our roundup of the best real estate lead generation tools covers options for each. As a paid source proves itself, move part of its profit into owned channels.
Tools that do this for you
Vulcan7 (expired and FSBO data)
Vulcan7 says every plan “includes premium leads, expert training, CRM, and a power dialer with phone number protection,” with billing from monthly to annual.
Limitations: no published prices, and FSBO is an add-on on the entry plan. Not for: agents who will not make daily outbound calls.
Carrot (owned seller lead websites)
Carrot lists its Individual plan at $119/month, or $99/month billed annually, with one website, 50 auto-created location pages, a free CarrotCRM and a call tracking number. It charges no setup fee and offers a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Limitations: it builds the site; traffic depends on your SEO or ads, and its pricing page examples are investor sites (wholesale, land, mobile homes) rather than agent sites. Not for: agents who need leads next week.
HighLevel (follow-up across every source)
HighLevel lists a Starter plan at $97/month with a 14-day free trial, and says usage-based charges apply for phone numbers, SMS, emails and premium AI. It can pull every vendor’s leads into one pipeline and run the instant text, call tasks and nurture above.
Limitations: it supplies no leads, and setup takes time. Not for: agents whose current CRM already sends instant replies and tasks.
Want it done for you?
If you would rather have a team build and run this for you, AtalosWeb, the digital marketing agency that publishes Realty Nodes, sets up lead generation systems for real estate agencies: websites, Google and Meta ads, SEO and CRM automation.
Frequently asked questions
How much do Zillow leads cost?
Zillow says Premier Agent pricing varies by market, with an average cost per connection of $223 in major metros and $139 elsewhere. Zillow Preferred (formerly Flex) is pay-at-close by invitation, with a 40% fee on seller-originated connections.
Are Realtor.com leads worth it?
It depends on your break-even. Realtor.com does not publish Connections Plus prices or the Concierge fee percentage, so run the calculator above with your quote.
What is pay per lead real estate?
You pay per lead, or for a monthly package with a set or estimated number of leads, such as Real Geeks’ $299/month social package with about 20 to 40 buyer leads.
Are exclusive leads better than shared leads?
Exclusive leads mean you are not racing other agents to the first call. Ask how many agents receive each lead before you compare prices.
Can I text purchased leads?
Only with consent that covers you. US rules require prior express written consent for autodialed telemarketing to cell phones. Check with your broker or state association for how this applies to you.
Sources
- Zillow: Premier Agent
- Zillow Preferred: FAQ, pricing and compliance policies
- Realtor.com: Connections Plus
- Realtor.com: ReadyConnect Concierge and Opcity is now ReadyConnect Concierge
- Market Leader: Homepage
- Real Geeks: Pricing
- Ylopo: Pricing
- CINC: Pricing
- REDX: Pricing
- Vulcan7: Packages
- Carrot: Pricing
- HighLevel: Pricing
- FTC: Q&A for Telemarketers and Sellers About DNC Provisions in the TSR
- 47 CFR 64.1200 (Cornell Legal Information Institute)
- NAR: Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA)
- Florida Realtors: Real estate inquiries often fail to reach agents (October 13, 2026)
- Mike DelPrete: Secret Shopping: 47% of Online Property Inquiries Are Ignored (August 13, 2024)


